Saturday, December 7, 2013

What Happens In The Village...

Today was a busy day! We awoke with the cock-a-doodle-doos of the village roosters and had a lovely breakfast of crushed rice with local spices, onions and peanuts. The weather was very pleasant, and it was fun to see the village cows and chickens wandering around looking for their breakfast as well! 

Our first activity was a visit to a local secondary school, which included students in grades six through ten. We met with teachers and administrators and asked questions about teacher and student attendance, classroom supplies and funding. Then we toured the classrooms, which were very orderly but Spartan.  Students were doubled at long desks and wore matching uniforms, and the classrooms did not have many adornments besides their blackboards.  The children were very excited to say “good morning” to us in English and ask about our education in America.  Many said that they wanted to become doctors and engineers.

Next we set off to see a few projects that Swades had organized with local communities.  We visited a spring that supplied drinking water to local communities and followed one of the pipes to a local village. There we met with community members and asked questions about water, healthcare, primary education and sanitation.  We were able to see
projects that Swades organized with the help of villagers to improve cattle stalls, implement mango grafting, and increase local fertilizer production. During our visit the children who had just gotten out of school were eager to speak with us in English and point out things around their village.  (Indian schools are in session for half days on
Saturday!)  We had a chance to see the village’s rice mill as well.



After this we stopped at a local primary care center to meet with the doctor on call.  We toured the facilities and asked questions about medical supplies and billing, illness incidence and facility procedures.  There were no patients in the center during our visit because we were there after-hours, but the facility looked very clean. The doctor’s biggest complaint was that rural practitioners are not adequately compensated for working in remote areas where they often lack housing and other facilities as well as earn smaller salaries.

Worn out from a long morning in the heat, we made it back to our hosting village for a delicious lunch of spiced lentil soup, rice, pickled vegetables and some type of roti made with rice flour. Luckily we had a break at this point to siesta. Many of us were beat! Later in the afternoon we ventured out to another local village for tea and a group discussion about local governance and property rights. The villagers talked a lot about the disruptive effects of urban
migration.  Looking around, it was eerie how few people there were aged 20 to 40.  Because of small returns to farming, the young people have been forced to move to Mumbai to work, pulling families apart.

After this meeting we returned to our host village to rest before dinner.  Some of us hung out at the local tea stall, while others played cards outside the host families’ house.  Dinner included rice, lentil soup, chapati and a sweet treat that we could not identify.  As we ate, the host families’ television set was turned on to “Mean
Girls,” which was a little too close to home.  We had hoped to meet with a local police officer after dinner, but unfortunately he was not able to get off of patrol in time.  Many of us were happily asleep by 9:30 pm as a result.



Friday, December 6, 2013

A Trip In Transition

After a morning meeting with Saugata Bhattacharya, Senior Vice President and Chief Economist at Axis Bank (India's third largest private sector bank) that covered everything from current account deficits to land reform, we boarded Zubin's Royal Fleet, this time bound for Kasar Malai, a remote village outside of Mumbai. It was our first experience with roadways outside the city center. Unfortunately, we cannot report that the pavement gets any smoother or the traffic any less insane upon leaving downtown Mumbai.

The cityscape slowly gave way to steadily more rural towns and villages as we drove further. We paused for lunch at the Indian equivalent of a rest stop (it turns out that dosas — a sort of fermented crepe and Indian staple containing rice batter and black lentils — are quite filling!) before continuing what had become a one lane "highway." The bus whizzed down this road with nearly reckless abandon. Unlike in America, there are no sections of the road on which passing slow-moving cars is illegal, and even if there were, we doubt Indian drivers would pay any heed. Narrowly missing both enormous potholes and other vehicles, we wound our way into the small, lush mountains that line the subcontinent's southwestern coast.

Upon reaching the Swades' regional office, we were briefed on the foundation's work in fostering sustainable agricultural practices, managing water supplies and promoting preventative healthcare in this seemingly forgotten corner of India. The managers in charge of each of these projects were more than eager to share the principles and progress related to each operation. We then re-boarded the bus and proceeded another 25 km to Kasar Malai itself.

In the village, the entire community gathered to welcome us at our arrival. Taking care to remove our shoes, we entered their community hall, where we were greeted with much pomp and circumstance and presented with flowers. The villagers were incredibly genuine and friendly — the household that had agreed to host us had a full and traditional Indian dinner consisting of rice, dhal, chapati and aloo gobi. We had no idea what to expect in terms of sleeping arrangements but were pleasantly surprised to find that we would not only be sleeping on mattresses, but would also be in a room with a tiled floor and a working ceiling fan! Tuckered out from a long bus ride and apprehension about our village stay, we were all in bed by 9:30pm.


Thursday, December 5, 2013

Getting to Know Mumbai

Our first meeting of the morning was with Leo Puri from UTI Mutual Fund, one of the most well-regarded public lenders in India. The UTI Tower was located somewhat outside the city center; the view from the conference room was spectacular! Mr. Puri discussed financial regulations, privatization versus disinvestment, the political economy of various policy proposals that the class is interested in, and his own work at UTI. Our conversation with Mr. Puri contrasted sharply with the meeting we had with the Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research’s professors — unlike the academics, Mr. Puri was eager to make decisive recommendations for and against specific policy proposals.

After our meeting with Mr. Puri, we piled back into the bus for a short break at the hotel. Even though we were supposed to have five hours between our first and second meetings of the day, the reality of traffic in Mumbai (think congested like an imminent stroke patient’s arteries, and cacophonous with people, car horns and hawkers at every turn) ate away well over half of our break time, most of which was spent regrouping for our second meeting of the day, with Manish Kejriwal (a Dartmouth alum) and others at Kedaara Capital Advisors LLP.

Our meeting with Mr. Kejriwal and his associates began just as the sun was setting and the view from the 38th floor of the Sunshine Tower — which overlooks a stretch of Mumbai skyline that includes a ninety-floor tower whose construction has been halted for over a year due to code violations — showed Mumbai off impressively. Mr. Kejriwal and his associates shared their educational backgrounds (IIT and American university degrees), and discussed their respective paths to Kedaara Capital. They then fielded questions on a wide range of topics, including the elections (who do they support? The BJP? Why? Because Modi will likely be more friendly to business) and what business needs from the next government.




Finally, Ronnie Screwvala and Zarina Mehta, founders of the Swades Foundation, hosted our group for dinner at their swank apartment. Most of the foundation’s executive team joined us for a delicious and enlightening meal. We learned about the foundation’s founding principles, organizational framework, and major projects. The dog lovers among us were also delighted to meet Ronnie and Zarina’s tremendously friendly and fluffy yellow labrador, Sprite.



By the end of the night, our entire group was tuckered out from the day itself and residual jet lag; most of us fell soundly asleep on the bus back to the hotel. As we have quickly realized, sleeping on the bus is imperative when traveling in Mumbai takes two to three times as long as would be the case in the States.

Wednesday, December 4, 2013

Pleasantries in the Pub

After everyone helped themselves to several healthy servings of breakfast, we climbed aboard our tour bus, nicknamed Zubin’s Royal Fleet (there is nothing royal about the suspension) and were off to our first of many meetings.

When our tour guide, ­­­­­­­Chetan, told us that it would take an hour and a half to get to the Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research, we assumed this would mean traveling to some unknown city in the distance. It turned out that Mumbai is so large, the roads so dilapidated and the traffic so slow, that it takes an hour and a half to merely get halfway across the city. The bus ride itself felt like a roller coaster, with jarring bumps and squeaking brakes. At every turn we saw a new set of clothing stores, a new slum, and a new motley crew of stray animals (dogs, cats, donkeys, horses, cows, chickens and the occasional goat). We even saw some people openly defecating on the side of the road. As a stark contrast to the dire poverty surrounding us, towering in the distance was the Mukesh Ambani building, a $50 million skyscraper that houses the five members of the Ambani family and their 110 servants. Of the 27 floors, five are reserved only for Mukesh's cars. Along the way, we crossed the Rajiv Gandhi Sea Link, constructed through a partnership with the federal government and a private construction firm, Infrastructure Developers PVT. As part of the move to create more accountability and transparency, the toll booths were emblazoned with several LED screens displaying the itemized revenue and costs associated with the construction and maintenance of the bridge, down to the monthly compound interest rate and the amortized depreciation rate.

After an hour and half of driving on the crowded Mumbai roads, with several accidents deftly avoided by the bus driver, including a shouting match with a motorcyclist after nearly running him down, we finally arrived at the Indira Gandhi Institute of Development. But instead of simply interviewing Sekhar Chandrasekhar, a development economist at the institute, when we arrived in the conference room we were greeted by Sekhar and four of his colleagues. The five professors all had different research specialties, so our 90 minute discussion encompassed topics from trade and labor regulations to agricultural productivity and urbanization. While the meeting served as a great way to refine many of our recommendations, we soon learned that attempting to nail down academics to clear, political palatable solution is nearly impossible task. (Brandon was skeptical)

After arriving back at the hotel after the meeting (and another bumpy hour and a half ride through the city) Chetan offered to take us on a walk around the city. As we avoided veering cars and held our breath as we passed the garbage dumps on the street, for the first time it truly felt like we were in India. Child beggars and street vendors accosted our group at every turn, attempting to extract a few rupees to quell the grumbling in their stomachs. One particularly ambitious girl actually wrapped a garland she was attempting to sell around Ashley’s wrist and followed us for several blocks in an effort to close the sale. Eventually we got tired of walking after reaching the Gateway to India (Chetan informed us that it was built during British Rule to welcome King James) and we decided to take taxis home. With five people and a driver to a taxi, we all managed to arrive back at the hotel within fifteen minutes — for the exorbitant price of less than a dollar! Obviously the inspiration for bumper cars, taxi rides in India include veering through long lines of motorcycles, buses, cars, auto rickshaws, and bicycles; swerving full speed into oncoming traffic; turning into the pathway of buses; and racing pedestrians to non-existent crosswalks, all to the constant symphony of blaring horns, the soundtrack of the Indian highway.

Our last meeting of the day was an informal dinner with Geeta and Greg Anand (two Dartmouth alums) at their new pub and restaurant The Barking Deer. Greg walked us through his experience attempting to open The Barking Deer, which took four years, 25+ licenses, and countless construction delays. He recounted several moments where he was nearly forced to close the entire businesses because of the uncertainty surrounding his brewing license. Meanwhile, Geeta discussed her work as a journalist with Wall Street Journal in the Mumbai office. A former Pulitzer Prize winner at the Boston Globe, her most recent work was a cover story on drug-resistant Tuberculosis, which has inspired many families back in the US to support Indian patients suffering with the disease. During the dinner, Geeta received a call from a family in Birmingham, Alabama who continues to send money to support a tuberculosis patient cited in her article. By then end of the three hour dinner, finally overwhelmed by jet lag, the entire crew fell asleep on the bus ride back to the hotel.

Quote of the Day:
“It’s Gandhi!” – Kevin (in reference to the Gandhi statue seen in a courtyard in Mumbai)

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

Hello from Mumbai!

Namaste from the Taj President Hotel in Mumbai! After touching down shortly after midnight, we arrived at our hotel around 2:30am. Our travels thus far have been nothing short of an adventure, as delays in the visa process forced Ashley to miss the group's flight from Boston to London, and a late departure out of Boston made us hustle to catch our connecting flight at Heathrow.

The London-Mumbai leg of the journey was particularly interesting and eventful. Of the five meals we've now been served on this trip, three of them have been curry (thanks British Airways!), yet we've only been on the subcontinent for about 12 hours. Our flight attendants have ranged from chipper Brits who warned us of Diet Coke's dire dietary effects to a sneaky Indian woman who raised our seats back into the upright position as we slept. As we descended into Mumbai, the attendants sprayed our cabin with what they announced was an antiseptic designed to prevent the spread of disease. We suspect, however, that it was merely meant to mask the odors of the city itself as the plane lost altitude. True to form, the Indian customs officials were predictably taciturn and even made Ashneil complete another visa form because he'd made the egregious error of filling his out in red ink.

Walking out the airport doors to meet an unknown city (and entirely new continent for most of us) was an experience none of us is likely to soon forget. I don't think it's too crass to say that Mumbai smells — like a mix of smoke, spice, incense and diesel fuel. The heat was intense even at 2am under a night sky, and the temperature is due to climb above 95F this afternoon. From what little of the city we've been exposed to so far, the inequality that we read about all term is even starker in person, with high-rise apartment complexes towering over tin-roofed slums and the homeless spending their nights on benches along the side of the road. We feel incredibly lucky to be safely ensconced in such nice hotel accommodations, where today we've taken advantage of a delicious and complimentary continental breakfast.

This afternoon, we embark to meet with one of India's top development economists and will later rendezvous with some Dartmouth alumni at one of Mumbai's newest eating and drinking establishments. We'll be posting pictures as soon as wifi in our hotel lobby allows.

Monday, December 2, 2013

London Calling

Greetings from Logan Airport! We've all safely arrived in Boston (minus one — see you in London, Ashley!) and will be boarding the first leg of our flight in about an hour.

We'd like to take this time to talk a little more about what we'll be doing in India. The Global Policy Leadership Practicum is a tool for connecting Dartmouth students to the world and providing real-world international policy experience for a select group of students engaged with the Rockefeller Center.

Our task this fall has been to learn as much as we can about India, with the goal of creating a task force report on the country's economic state of affairs. Together, we are in the process of preparing this report, which will make specific policy recommendations on everything from fiscal concerns to issues surrounding caste and gender. The hypothetical audience for the report is senior leaders in the Indian government, and other such policy types. The report aims to take a substantive, politically nuanced, historically accurate and culturally sensitive look at India's economic situation and offer suggestions that are as specific and actionable as possible

We will spend the next two and a half weeks meeting with local policy leaders, from politicians and academics to journalists, business leaders, and other "on the ground" experts. Stay tuned for updates as we make our way to Mumbai!